Thermal Action on Steel — Fire Design & Elevated Temperature

ISO 834 standard fire curve, section factor (Am/V or Hp/A), critical temperature method, steel strength reduction at elevated temperature, fire resistance ratings, and protection methods.

Steel behavior at elevated temperature

Steel does not burn, but it loses strength and stiffness rapidly above 300 degrees C. At 400 degrees C, steel retains approximately 100 percent of its room-temperature yield strength. At 550 degrees C, strength drops to approximately 60 percent. At 700 degrees C, only about 23 percent remains. This is why unprotected steel beams and columns fail within 15-20 minutes in a standard fire — the steel temperature reaches 550-700 degrees C long before the fire is controlled.

The design strategy for steel in fire is to either (a) protect the steel from heat so it stays below a critical temperature during the required fire resistance period, or (b) design the member to carry the fire-condition loads at reduced strength.

Steel strength reduction factors

Temperature (deg C) ky,theta (yield reduction) kE,theta (modulus reduction) Yield Retention (%)
20 1.000 1.000 100
200 1.000 0.900 100
300 1.000 0.800 100
400 1.000 0.700 100
500 0.780 0.600 78
550 0.625 0.510 63
600 0.470 0.310 47
700 0.230 0.130 23
800 0.110 0.090 11
900 0.060 0.068 6
1000 0.040 0.045 4

Source: EN 1993-1-2 Table 3.1, AISC Appendix 4 Table A-4.2.1. Values are similar across all codes.

Critical temperature at common utilization ratios

Utilization Ratio mu_0 Critical Temperature (deg C) Meaning
0.20 730 Very lightly loaded
0.30 680 Lightly loaded
0.40 640 Moderate loading
0.50 585 Half-capacity utilization
0.60 540 Moderately heavy loading
0.70 500 Heavily loaded
0.80 460 Near full utilization
0.90 420 Very heavily loaded

Lightly loaded members have higher critical temperatures, meaning they can withstand longer fire exposure before failure. This is why heavy columns often need less fire protection than light beams.

Section factor (Am/V or Hp/A)

The section factor determines how quickly a steel member heats up. It is the ratio of the heated surface area to the volume (mass) of steel. Higher section factors mean faster heating (thinner, lighter members heat faster).

Section factors for common shapes

Section Exposure Am/V (m^-1) Hp/A (in^-1) Heating Rate
W8x31 4-sided 135 3.44 Fast
W12x40 4-sided 104 2.65 Fast
W14x82 4-sided 78 1.98 Moderate
W14x82 3-sided (slab) 61 1.55 Moderate
W21x44 4-sided 97 2.47 Fast
W24x55 4-sided 87 2.22 Moderate
W24x55 3-sided (slab) 68 1.73 Moderate
W27x94 4-sided 65 1.65 Slow
W36x150 4-sided 48 1.22 Slow
HSS6x6x3/8 4-sided 95 2.42 Fast
HSS10x10x1/2 4-sided 58 1.47 Slow
HSS12x12x5/8 4-sided 48 1.22 Slow

Heavy sections (W36x150, HSS12x12x5/8) have low section factors and heat slowly. Light sections (W8x31, W12x40) have high section factors and reach critical temperature in 10-15 minutes unprotected.

Time to reach 550 deg C (unprotected, ISO 834 fire)

Section Factor (m^-1) Time to 550 deg C Time to 700 deg C
30 35 min 55 min
50 22 min 35 min
70 16 min 26 min
100 12 min 19 min
150 8 min 14 min
200 6 min 10 min
300 4 min 7 min

Unprotected steel with Am/V > 100 m^-1 fails within 12 minutes. This is why most building codes require fire protection for structural steel.

Critical temperature method

The simplest fire design approach determines the temperature at which the member fails under fire-condition loads. Fire loads are reduced from ambient design: the EN 1993-1-2 fire combination is approximately 0.6 to 0.7 times the ambient ULS loads.

The utilization factor in fire: mu_0 = E_fi,d / R_fi,d,0, where E_fi,d = fire-condition design effect, R_fi,d,0 = ambient design resistance.

The critical temperature theta_cr can be read from charts or calculated: theta_cr = 39.19 x ln(1 / (0.9674 x mu_0^3.833) - 1) + 482 (EN 1993-1-2 Eq. 4.22).

For mu_0 = 0.5: theta_cr = 39.19 x ln(1/(0.9674 x 0.5^3.833) - 1) + 482 = 39.19 x ln(1/0.0678 - 1) + 482 = 39.19 x ln(13.75) + 482 = 39.19 x 2.62 + 482 = 585 degrees C.

If the unprotected steel reaches 585 degrees C in 15 minutes but the required fire resistance is 60 minutes, fire protection must slow the heating rate so that 585 degrees C is not reached for at least 60 minutes.

Fire protection methods

Spray-applied cementitious (SFRM)

Parameter Typical Value Notes
Density 200-400 kg/m^3 Lightweight to medium
Thermal conductivity 0.08-0.15 W/mK Varies by product
Application thickness 10-50 mm Per UL design
Application method Spray (wet mix) High application rate
Surface prep Clean, primed steel Primer must be compatible
Durability 30+ years (indoor) Fragile, not for exposed exterior
Fire ratings achieved R30 to R240 Most common for buildings
Relative cost 1.0x (baseline) Cheapest per sqm

SFRM is the most common fire protection for structural steel in buildings. It is applied by spraying a wet cementitious mix onto primed steel. The resulting coating is relatively fragile and typically concealed behind architectural finishes.

Intumescent paint

Parameter Typical Value Notes
Dry film thickness 0.5-5 mm (ambient) Expands 20-50x in fire
Expansion ratio 20-50x original thickness Forms insulating char
Application Spray or roller Requires multiple coats
Surface prep SP 10 / Sa 2.5 minimum Same as high-performance coating
Durability 25+ years Aesthetic, can be top-coated
Fire ratings achieved R30 to R120 Limited by coating thickness
Relative cost 3-5x SFRM Premium for exposed steel

Intumescent coatings are used for architecturally exposed structural steel where SFRM would be unsightly. The coating expands when heated to form a thick insulating char layer. Limited to R120 for most products.

Board enclosure

Parameter Typical Value Notes
Board types Gypsum, calcium silicate Factory-produced, consistent
Board thickness 12-50 mm per layer Multiple layers for higher ratings
Installation Mechanical fixing Prefabricated, dry trade
Surface prep Minimal Board encloses the member
Durability 30+ years Robust, can be decorated
Fire ratings achieved R30 to R240 Any rating achievable
Relative cost 2-3x SFRM More expensive but clean finish

Board enclosures provide a clean, factory-finished appearance. They are preferred where the fire protection must also serve as an architectural finish, or in clean-room and hospital environments where SFRM dust is unacceptable.

Concrete encasement

Parameter Typical Value Notes
Minimum cover 40-50 mm Per code requirements
Reinforcement Light mesh or ties For crack control
Fire ratings achieved R60 to R240+ Any rating achievable
Relative cost 4-6x SFRM Heavy, labor-intensive
Weight impact Significant Increases foundation loads

Concrete encasement is the traditional method. It provides excellent fire protection and additional corrosion protection but adds significant weight and cost. Used primarily for columns where concrete fill is also required for structural reasons.

Worked example — fire protection thickness

Member: W14x82 beam, 3-sided exposure (slab above), required fire rating R60 (60 minutes). Critical temperature = 585 degrees C. Section factor Hp/A = 1.55 in^-1 (3-sided) = 61 m^-1.

Using board protection (gypsum, thermal conductivity lambda_p = 0.20 W/mK, density = 800 kg/m^3):

The required protection thickness can be estimated from EN 1993-1-2 Annex D or manufacturer data. For Am/V = 61 m^-1 and theta_cr = 585 degrees C at 60 minutes, typical gypsum board thickness = 15 mm (single layer).

Using intumescent coating: for the same section factor and fire rating, typical dry film thickness = 1.2-1.5 mm. Intumescent coatings expand 20-50 times their thickness when exposed to heat, forming an insulating char layer.

Spray-applied cementitious fireproofing (vermiculite/cement, lambda_p = 0.12 W/mK): required thickness approximately 20-25 mm for R60 at this section factor.

Fire protection thickness by rating and section factor (SFRM)

Section Factor (m^-1) R30 (mm) R60 (mm) R90 (mm) R120 (mm)
50 10 20 28 35
100 15 25 35 45
150 18 30 42 52
200 20 35 48 60
300 25 42 58 72

Approximate thicknesses for cementitious SFRM (density 300 kg/m^3, lambda = 0.12 W/mK). Actual values per manufacturer UL listings.

Code comparison — fire design

Aspect AISC App. 4 AS 4100 Sec. 12 EN 1993-1-2 CSA S16 Annex K
Fire curve ASTM E119 (similar to ISO 834) AS 1530.4 (ISO 834) ISO 834 CAN/ULC S101 (ISO 834)
Load combination 1.2D + 0.5L (per IBC) Per AS 1170.0 fire comb. EN 1991-1-2 Eq. 6.11b 1.0D + 0.5L
Critical temp approach App. 4 Section 4.2.4 Cl. 12.5 Cl. 4.2.4 Annex K
Fire ratings Per IBC Table 601 Per NCC Spec C1.1 Per national annex Per NBC Table 3.2.2
Section factor notation Hp/A (in^-1) ksm (m^2/tonne) Am/V (m^-1) Hp/A (m^-1)

All four codes use essentially the same steel property reduction factors and section factor approach. The main differences are in load combinations and how the required fire rating is determined by the building code.

Common pitfalls

  1. Assuming all steel members need the same protection thickness. Heavy columns (low Am/V) heat much slower than light beams (high Am/V). Specifying uniform protection thickness wastes material on heavy members and under-protects light members.
  2. Ignoring 3-sided vs 4-sided exposure. A beam protected by a concrete slab on its top flange has a significantly lower section factor than the same beam with 4-sided exposure. Using 4-sided values for beams with composite decks over-specifies protection.
  3. Not checking connection temperatures. Bolts and welds at connections can reach higher temperatures than the mid-span beam if the connection is at a thin web or exposed to fire from multiple sides. EN 1993-1-2 Clause 4.2.1 requires connection checks.
  4. Specifying intumescent coatings for concealed steelwork. Intumescent coatings must be inspected for correct dry film thickness. If the steel is concealed behind cladding during construction and later, inspection and maintenance are impractical. Board or spray protection is preferred for concealed members.
  5. Forgetting to account for thermal expansion. A 12 m steel beam heated to 550 deg C expands by approximately 12 x 550 x 12 x 10^-6 = 79 mm. Without expansion joints or sliding connections, this force can damage surrounding construction.
  6. Using SFRM on architecturally exposed steel. SFRM has a rough, unfinished appearance. For exposed steel, specify intumescent paint or board enclosure that provides a clean architectural finish.

Frequently asked questions

What is the section factor and why does it matter? It is the ratio of heated surface perimeter to cross-section area (Am/V or Hp/A). Higher values mean faster heating. A W8x31 (Am/V = 135 m^-1) reaches critical temperature in 12 minutes unprotected, while a W36x150 (Am/V = 48 m^-1) takes 35 minutes. Section factor determines the required fire protection thickness.

How much does fire protection add to steel cost? SFRM adds approximately 5-10% to structural steel cost. Intumescent paint adds 15-25%. Board enclosure adds 10-15%. Concrete encasement adds 20-30%. The cost depends on required fire rating, section factor, and accessibility.

Do I need to fire-protect steel beams in a parking garage? It depends on the occupancy and local code. Open parking garages (per IBC Section 406.5) may not require fire-rated structural steel if they meet ventilation requirements. Enclosed parking garages typically require 1-hour fire protection per IBC Table 601.

What is the difference between ASTM E119 and ISO 834? They are nearly identical fire curves. Both reach approximately 535 deg C at 5 minutes, 743 deg C at 30 minutes, and 842 deg C at 60 minutes. ISO 834 is used in Europe and Australia. ASTM E119 is used in North America. Design results are interchangeable.

Can I use the critical temperature method for all members? Yes for simple members (beams, columns in axial load or bending). For members with combined loading, complex support conditions, or where the temperature distribution is non-uniform, the advanced calculation method per EN 1993-1-2 Clause 4.3 or finite element analysis may be required.

How does fire protection affect steel connections? Connections must also achieve the required fire rating. Bolt temperatures should not exceed the critical temperature of the connected member. For demand-critical welds in seismic systems, fire protection must cover the entire weld length. Connections at member ends often receive thinner protection due to access, which is a common oversight.

Run this calculation

Related references

Disclaimer

This page is for educational and reference use only. It does not constitute professional engineering advice. All design values must be verified against the applicable standard and project specification before use. The site operator disclaims liability for any loss arising from this information.